For the record, if another server was to open up and the little community we have right now gets split, I will be out of there. I assume a decent amount of other people will be as well, given the lack of people available for games.
It can be difficult to get a game going in the first place, so splitting the community, in my opinion, will be terrible for the game. It's easy to say X, X, and X will leave so everyone will follow, but is that true? Will you only have experienced people and groups of friends go? Will there be a group of people who stick with IL and refuse to go?
As much as you want this new server, and for the record, I personally think this one is fine, just remember the big picture. For the greater good, sometimes the little have to suffer.