I had just left Smeagol's icon up also, despite posting myself that it should be removed, but then after this big $200 tournament I was like, well, I guess it's past time to update this. It seems like if there's a repeating tournament or frequent tournaments, the icon should rotate, and that if it's going to be a lasting icon it should be a one-of-a-kind yearly event.
I mean, that makes sense, right? But I'm not just gonna go write a "rule" at this point yet... I'm wondering first if there's a consensus that this makes sense and also if anyone ever promised Smeagol that every winner would get this icon for good or if that was just something he came up with himself.